Montreal’s Startup Scene

Seventeen years ago today, I moved from Toronto to Montreal. This was shortly after the October ’95 referendum. At the time most people were moving west not east. For 14 out of those 17 years, I’ve been a part of the Montreal startup community. But in two short weeks, I’ll be packing my bags again and heading west to start full time at FreshBooks.

I’ve lived through the highs and lows of our startup scene in Montreal. I remember when Austin Hill was on US national television talking about internet privacy for Zero Knowledge. I lived through the dark days of 2002 – 2004 when almost nothing was getting funded. We were actually lucky here in Quebec. Our province has a longstanding commitment to funding innovation and so provincially funded VCs were still cutting some cheques.

I’ve enjoyed some exits along the way. Some good. Some not so good. I have watched the startup community really come together in the past few years since 2008. Attendance at community events has grown and grown. Events like Accelerate Montreal and the International Startup Festival beautifully highlight this great community.

Finally, I have had the privilege of meeting a huge portion of Montreal’s founder community during my time at Real Ventures. Real has funded more Montreal-based startups than anyone. So we have had a great vantage point to view the development of this community.

As I look at where the community stands today there are lots of things to be excited about:

- More funding than ever. Real remains active. iNovia, Celtic and Rho have all closed new funds recently. BDC, while a national fund, is headquartered in Montreal.

- More visibility than ever thanks to the growing pool of funded companies and events like Startup Festival

- Some truly amazing companies, particularly in e-commerce. Beyond The Rack has gone from idea to over 200 employees in a few short years. Frank & Oak looks like it’s targeting similar growth.

Despite all the good stuff, my one concern is that we are not building enough “big” companies here. Beyond The Rack is one of the few exceptions. If you look at leading startup hubs like Silicon Valley, Boston and NYC they are anchored by big, public tech companies. These companies acquire local startups, hire young engineering grads at a ferocious pace and contribute in many other ways to make those communities self-perpetuating. We lack that here in Montreal.

And from an investor perspective, as I have posted many times before: VC is about those rare extreme outcomes (like the 37x return on Radian 6) not averages. One homerun outcome can produce many years of follow on funds. We need successes like that (not just in Montreal) in order to ensure our community continues to have the capital it needs to grow.

So as I leave Montreal to join a company with huge, long-term ambitions, my challenge to the rest of the Montreal community is to build more big companies. Don’t sell early. Go big! We have the talent and the capital you need to make it happen.

 

  • Joey

    Nice read Mark.

  • http://twitter.com/bruno_goulet Bruno Goulet

    My friend, you will be missed… I have always appreciated your sharp mind and valued your deep hands-on experience. I would take you on my team anytime. Hopefully we will have the chance to work together again. Wishing you the very best! (By the way, our new contract management SaaS is ready to go live. Maybe Biztree and Freshbooks should work together…)

    • http://startupcfo.ca/ Mark MacLeod

      Bruno,

      Thank you very much for the kind words!

      Given our mutual focus on small business customers, I am sure our companies can find a way to work together.

      Mark

  • http://www.facebook.com/david.nault.7 David Nault

    Thanks for sharing. Totally agree about building big and entrepreneurs need to aim above the bar. Like you said, Quebec has the funds and talent to do it. Hope to see you go big in your next venture as well !

    • http://startupcfo.ca/ Mark MacLeod

      Thanks David. Definitely going big on my new gig.

  • http://wmougayar.com/ William Mougayar

    Congratulations Mark & welcome back to the real world :)

    What will your role be at FreshBooks?

    • http://startupcfo.ca/ Mark MacLeod

      Thanks William. Running biz and corp dev.

      • http://wmougayar.com/ William Mougayar

        I saw. Great. Go for growth!

  • Chad Loeven

    Nice post Mark. You will be missed. And a valid point. Pertinent to our own recent exit. We aren’t complaining of course, but a choice was made to exit relatively early, rather than swing for the fences. I would add that a factor in that choice was that Montreal lacks an ecosystem for enterprise tech. The focus is on consumer/mobile/social. It was much easier to communicate our story to a receptive audience south of the border than up here.

    • http://startupcfo.ca/ Mark MacLeod

      Hey Chad,

      It’s funny, relative to other cities, I’d say we are even short on consumer tech depth. We are very strong in gaming, pro graphics, machine learning and of course telecom. The biggest issue with going big from up here is access to enough capital to compete with better funded US competitors.

  • http://twitter.com/el_fennec Ilyes Hassani

    I would love to have your advice on how do you consider exits as a VC.

    As an entrepreneur I agree 100% when you say ”Don’t sell early. Go big!”. But for VCs it seems different to me, I believe that exits are even more important for you guys. Let’s say you invest $X on a start-up and there’s an exit offer giving you a 15x return do you consider it or not ?

    I guess that you wanna hit a home-run with an IPO or a billion-dollar valuation, but what if there is a very lucrative offer giving you x15 return ? How do you know that you potentially can hit a home-run and decline a x15 return ? Solely on traction ? How do you evaluate the potential ? On income increase ? traction ? sales ?

    Thanks in advance.

    • http://startupcfo.ca/ Mark MacLeod

      As a VC I would never sell something that is continuing to grow. You always hold on to your star performers. Most investments don’t work so if something’s working you want to hold onto it as long as possible.

      But also to be clear – I would take a 15x return any day.

  • http://twitter.com/el_fennec Ilyes Hassani

    Awesome post as usual, heading to the Valley Mark ?

    • http://startupcfo.ca/ Mark MacLeod

      Toronto